Enter your vote today! A new poll has been created for the eurobrit group: Do you think that the current WEBC raider rules reflect the historical nature of...
eurobrit@yahoogroups....
Feb 10, 2002 12:04 pm
773
Hi Allan, Thanks for your response. ... I certainly appreciate the extra strategic and tactical flexibility that one is afforded by the WEBC raider rules....
Chux, I'm no player in WEBC but I used both those sets of rules which have been adopted by the French Hobby. I'm surprised also to see the point of the having...
... If the game were supposed to be that historical, then the Saxons, Angles, and Jutes would be combined into one nation; similarly the Irish, Scots, and...
Hi all, About the question to know if raiders must be active along the game or just for a time limited period. Are this question so important. The most...
... Hi John, Thanks for your reply to my post. Nice to hear from you after so long. :-) ... No real argument here. I just wonder how you would fit these...
... Hi Yann, Thanks for going to the trouble of a lengthy post... it's probably worth me replying to it bit by bit. ... Don't be surprised. I am not question...
JDG writes: Frankly, the WEBC rule set is so bogus to begin with that anyone who has any respect for the _real_ rules is ineligible to participate in the ...
Yann says: Could you quote the precise point of rules you have in mind in WEBC II set of rules when you say they are neither GG nor AH and they were decided ...
Sorry Scot but this is plain stupid. I have always played GG and was not aware of AH till I started playing online last year. I must admit the notion of people...
Using your logic, we should have just selected one of the existing rules sets. AH as interpreted for AvalonCon was the official US rules set approved by the...
... The French Defi has never used GG-based rules, as far as I know, but the rules previously used were an interpretation of AH. Now we are using WEBC rules...
... Ah, Scot you fail to see my logic. I we adopted the AH rules then some of us would not be pissed off, i.e. AH players. This will not work. Only when we are...
Ah, Scot you fail to see my logic. I we adopted the AH rules then some of us would not be pissed off, i.e. AH players. This will not work. Only when we are all...
"All I can say is that I'll not be changing," he said. "I will go to the grave with the convictions I have." Ian Paisley F. Scott Pfeiffer Pfeiffer & Gant, PA ...
Would it be possible for you all to trim down your messages so that not every mail contains all previous mails also? If not, I guess I have to unsubscribe the...
... [snip] ... The above goes for me, also. But in my view, what we got is not OK - it is Calvinball and not Britannia at all. ... I feel the WEBC has already...
"All I can say is that I'll not be changing," he said. "I will go to the grave with the convictions I have." Ian Paisley What's this? A new Britannia variant...
Gents, For every fool who shouts "It's crud" there are scores of Britannia players enjoying their games. The WEBC rules are no more "made up" than any other...
I agree with Scott, rules are differents from AH, GG, French Defi and WEBC1 2 or ... But our goal is to play all together, have fun and good games. The ranking...
... They only "had the best feedback" because most of the people allowed on the committee that made them were people who have no respect for the written rules...
... I have to agree with this. i was astounded at some of the rules decisions taken with the first WEBC. I feel that rules committees should only clarify...
Yann, (et.al.) Your memory of events is somewhat different from mine, and I think that we had different ideas about how the process would work from the start....
... And which written rules would that be? In an objective sense, it would have to be the original first-version Gibsons Games rules of Britannia, since they...
... (That was feedback from the players BTW) ... In light of Torben's post let's look at some of the main differences between GG2 and AH2, and see how they...
