Oh That LC Review! Unknown to libraries, bookshops, magazine shops in these parts. Guess I'll just have to rely on the objective interpretions of our objective...
I do put it to you, however, that it is this very silence of experts on the "other side", that gives you the duty to pass along to your readers, evidence that...
In a message dated 8/1/02 8:56:54 AM GMT Daylight Time, ... I apologise, but I assumed you would know the publication I was referring to. The LC Review is...
... Agreed, absolutely! ... I've never read Cohen or Clark (Leach's is the ONLY modern biography that I have read); but for what it's worth -- I'm pretty darn...
Mike, I think it is OTT to say that because Anne Clark has not responded then your ideas must prevail. I'd suspect that Anne has no idea whatsoever that you...
keith
keith@...
Aug 1, 2002 12:38 pm
6440
... Can I ask a really naive question here? Exactly what kind of kissing are we talking about? A friendly kiss on the cheek? A continental- style kiss of...
Mike wrote: << So, how can it be justified to attack Leach here for her assumed 'exaggerations' or whatever while saying nothing about the huge omission ...
'Up above the world you fly, Like a tea-tray in the sky. Twinkle, twinkle-------'[AAIW, C7] Flying tea-tray? "Whose face was very like a crow, With eyes, like...
This discussion began because Karoline had problems with August Imholtz's saying that it was "indisputable" that Carroll had a "fascination with Alice ...
In a message dated 8/1/02 1:39:15 PM GMT Daylight Time, ... Keith it's not that I or anyone 'want' a response, it's that one is actually neccessary isn't it?...
... I don't know. ... Back then, quite probably true. And this probably remained true, for Dodgson, till some of his biographers of the 1930's and later, who ...
Matt - So, from your words do I take it that if Leach had just refused to say anything about the 1885 letter , the way that Cohen refuses to say anything ...
In a message dated 8/1/02 2:06:45 PM GMT Daylight Time, ... I think it was generally a mouth-to-mouth kiss, but obviously nothing too intense! A five-minute...
... No, it does not! Matt is *not* Cohen, Clark, Taylor, Bakewell, etc.; therefore he is *not* committed to those epithets. Neither am I. But for those who...
... OK, he's been writing about CLD in a general way (not a large output, I gather); but since purchasing Karoline's book, has he REPEATED any of the claims to...
Sorry if I sound thick about this, my excuse is that I got interested in Carroll after Karoline's views had already been known for some time. But many people...
Mike wrote: << Well, you are entitled to your opinion., but what it seems to boil down to is 'I am prepared to trash Leach for the slightest omission but...
... *Wonderland*'s Alice---if I read her right. I rather think they are an admittance that she is no longer that little girl that was once "Alice," but is now...
Ruth Berman
berma005@...
Aug 1, 2002 7:22 pm
6453
Keith, If I happen to be one of the stooges, I would like to be Curly. I could stand for Larry or Moe, but I will not abide being Shemp. It is not Mike's job...
... Let us not forget that the word "stooge" has different meanings over the Pond. When the Three Stooges toured the U.K. in the thirties, they had to bill...
Joel, excellent when can you start? I loved those films at the cinema when I was a kid! Keith W ... From: "markbwrabbit" <mxburste@...> To:...
keith
keith@...
Aug 1, 2002 8:49 pm
6456
Karoline writes: <Yes, I think the problem is you are maybe not picking up an important distinction I am making. I say 'there is absolutely no evidence to...
In a message dated 01/08/2002 09:20:26 GMT Daylight Time, mikeindex@... ... ?? I'm not sure I understand this Mike. How can copyright precent a person ...
AnisaT@...
Aug 1, 2002 9:53 pm
6458
In a message dated 01/08/2002 17:14:52 GMT Daylight Time, jbuch@... ... I suppose it depends what you call the short term. My feelings are that...
AnisaT@...
Aug 1, 2002 11:28 pm
6459
In a message dated 8/1/02 9:55:31 PM GMT Daylight Time, DOYLE60@... ... Just to be factually accurate - that isn't true at all. Actually Cohen is one of...
... Thank you for the interesting post, Mike. Before you accuse Matt of hiding under the rug, let me warn you that he is offline until Monday (and yes, he went...
... Thanks for that Mark, but of course I am not accusing Matt of anything. He accused Leach of rug-sweeping if you remember, so it was just a little joke on...
... Interesting post Jenny, but surely, if a man's priority is 'structuring a life to avoid sin', then if he's heterosexual one thing he doesn't do is hang out...
... I prefer The Goons myself. Very Carrollian humour there, but then Spike Milligan was a fan of Lewis Carroll too. Take a listen to the sketch beginning...
Hi Deb - definitely the Goons, yes! To your other question - whether Mum approves or not has very little bearing on what females actually do these days anyways...
